Skip to main content

How to choose your COGS tracking method in Finaloop

Compare the purchase-based, sales-based and InventoryIQ methods for recording cost of goods sold (COGS) in Finaloop and pick the one that fits your inventory, so your P&L and balance sheet record COGS the right way.

Written by Ryan

About

There are different ways to set up and track inventory and cost of goods sold (COGS) in Finaloop. There isn't a one size fits all method and selecting the right method is an important step in creating an inventory management process that really works for you.

During the trial period we ask you to select an inventory method for COGS, on the Choose your COGS tracking method screen in Inventory. You're not "married" to a specific method, and it can be changed for any year with open books.

If you're not sure which method is best for your business, then read on! We recommend you also check out this video on choosing your Finaloop COGS method.



1. Why you need an inventory method

Let's start with the basics.

There are different ways of calculating the cost of the inventory (stock) you hold, and the cost of the inventory you sell, or your COGS.

  • The method you select tells us how we should be recording your COGS in your P&L and your inventory in your balance sheet.

  • Having this control and visibility helps you better manage these costs, optimize gross profit, and fine tune your pricing.

Whichever way you look at it, you have to decide on how inventory is calculated and reported in your books.


2. COGS method options

In Finaloop, you can track your COGS using one of three methods. Here's who each one is best for:

Method

Purchase based

Sales based

InventoryIQ

Inventory models

Brands with less than $3,000 in average inventory per month, or dropshippers who pay vendors shortly after receiving the bill (no timing difference)

Brands with more than $3,000 in average inventory per month, or dropshippers with payment terms with their vendors (timing delays between bill and payments)

Brands with more than $3,000 in average inventory per month

Landed cost visibility

N/A

Has landed costs through an inventory management system (IMS), warehouse management system (WMS), or enterprise resource planning system (ERP)

Has no landed cost or incorrect landed cost visibility

Purchase based

  • Using purchase based COGS, we record your COGS at the time you purchase inventory, unrelated to when you actually sell your products.

  • Purchase based works best for brands that hold little inventory, usually below $3,000.

  • It also works best for dropshippers when vendor bills are paid on or very close to the date of the bill.

  • At year-end, Finaloop adjusts your inventory balance to reflect your actual inventory and COGS, based on the year-end inventory balance you give us in the Wrap up {year} inventory mission, ensuring your books remain tax-ready.

Sales based

  • Using sales based, your inventory purchases are recorded as inventory in your Balance Sheet and COGS are calculated when you sell inventory based on a cost per unit or COGS you provide to us.

  • It allows you to connect your COGS with your actual sales data, but requires you to calculate your own landed costs per SKU.

  • This method is great for brands with more than $3,000 on average in inventory value each month who already have a strong set up to calculate their landed costs, for example in an IMS, a WMS, or an ERP.

  • It also works best for dropshippers who have payment terms with their vendors and don't pay the bill upon receipt.

  • If you currently use spreadsheets to calculate your landed cost, we recommend using InventoryIQ instead.

InventoryIQ

  • InventoryIQ is a real-time inventory management system that automatically calculates your landed costs based on your purchase orders and tracks your inventory and COGS on a unit-by-unit basis using the first in, first out (FIFO) method.

  • It includes PO creation, automated landed cost calculation, real-time broken-down COGS, warehouse stock tracking, recipes (bill of materials) and assemblies, inventory vendors balance, and more.

  • With InventoryIQ, COGS are recorded when you sell your products and we track your shipments, transfers, and receipts as well.

  • This method is great for brands with more than $3,000 in average inventory value each month who are looking for a more robust way to track their cost per unit, manage their POs, and view their stock unit levels directly in Finaloop.

  • InventoryIQ is an add-on (marked Add-on in the method list). To start it, contact our team at [email protected].


3. Features and benefits of each method

There are no hard and fast rules that determine which inventory method you use, but here are the features of each method.

Feature / Benefit

Purchase based

Sales based

InventoryIQ

Real-time COGS calculation

No

Yes

Yes

Automated landed cost calculation

No

No

Yes

More accurate reflection of gross profit and insights re pricing

No

Yes

Yes, most accurate

Tracking of on-hand units per SKU

No

No

Yes

Purchase orders (POs)

No

No

Yes

Bill of materials / recipes

No

No

Yes

Multiple warehouse tracking

No

No

Yes

Shipments and receipt syncing

No

No

Yes

Working with external IMS, WMS, or ERP (and want to continue)

No

Yes

No


4. The impact on cash or accrual accounts

All COGS methods can apply for cash or accrual basis taxpayers. However, based on the IRS tax rules, COGS are reported on an accrual basis for both cash and accrual taxpayers, unless you have an IRS tax exemption for small businesses.

In other words, even if you select the purchase based method, we'll make an adjustment at year end to ensure your COGS are not overstated for tax purposes, in line with the accrual rules.

For more about the exemption, see the section "Exception for small business taxpayers" in Purchase based COGS: Everything you need to know.


5. Select your COGS method

To select your COGS method:

  1. On any Inventory page, click Inventory settings (top right), then open the General tab.

  2. Under COGS tracking method, find the year in the table (columns Period, Status, COGS tracking method).

  3. For a period marked Active, select Purchase based or Sales based from the dropdown. If this is not your first year in Finaloop, each year has its own row, so you can apply different methods to different years.

  4. In the Save changes? bar, click Save.

Note: To use more than one method within the same year (Split period), or to move to InventoryIQ, contact our team at [email protected].


6. Change your COGS method

Generally, you can only choose one tracking method for each year (to avoid major accounting and tax issues). But, you can always decide to change a tracking method for different years if your initial choice no longer fits your needs. Periods marked Closed books can't be changed.


Related articles


Need help?

If you have any other questions, or are still not sure which method makes the most sense for you, contact us at [email protected]. We're happy to help!

Did this answer your question?